Amazon Buy with Prime: Is It Worth It? Fees, Pros & Cons

Amazon’s Buy with Prime is making waves in the direct-to-consumer (DTC) space. With major brands like Adidas integrating it into their website and app, many business owners are wondering: Is Buy with Prime the right move for my brand?

This blog post will break down what Buy with Prime is, its benefits, drawbacks, costs, and whether it’s a viable option for your business.

What Is Buy with Prime?

Buy with Prime is Amazon’s solution for DTC brands looking to offer Prime benefits on their own websites. With it, brands can provide Prime members with the same fast, free shipping they expect on Amazon—but without selling directly on Amazon’s marketplace.

Amazon handles fulfillment, shipping, and returns, while merchants still own the customer relationship and sales process. It integrates with most eCommerce platforms, making it appealing for brands wanting to leverage Amazon’s logistics while maintaining control of their brand presence.

Buy with Prime Requirements

To enroll in Buy with Prime, a brand must:

• Have a U.S.-based business authorized to operate in the U.S.
• Own an eCommerce website that is compatible with most eCommerce platforms.
• Have a Professional Seller Central account to import Amazon product catalog data.
• Set up an Amazon Pay account for streamlined checkout.

The Benefits of Buy with Prime

Many brands that have adopted Buy with Prime have seen increased conversion rates and improved fulfillment efficiency. Here are some of the core advantages:

Higher Conversion Rates

According to Amazon, merchants using Buy with Prime see an average 25% increase in conversion rates. The Prime badge fosters trust and reduces purchase hesitation.

Amazon’s Trusted Fulfillment

With Amazon handling storage, shipping, and returns, brands no longer need to worry about logistical headaches. This can significantly simplify operations.

Access to Customer Data

Unlike Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), Buy with Prime allows brands to collect valuable customer information, including:

• Names
• Email addresses
• Shipping addresses

This enables brands to own the customer relationship, build direct email marketing campaigns, and drive long-term customer loyalty.

Seamless Checkout Process

Customers can check out using Amazon Pay, leveraging their saved payment and shipping information. This reduces friction and increases completed purchases.

Potential Cost Savings

For brands with high fulfillment costs, Amazon’s logistics network might offer cheaper and faster shipping than other third-party providers.

The Drawbacks of Buy with Prime

While Buy with Prime presents many advantages, there are notable concerns for brands considering adoption.

Costs Can Add Up

There are multiple fees associated with Buy with Prime, including:

• Service Fee – 3% of order value (minimum $1 per order)
• Fulfillment Fee – Starting at $5.33 per unit, depending on size and weight
• Payment Processing Fee – 2.4% of order value + $0.30 per transaction

For brands with low-margin products, these fees could cut deeply into profitability.

Limited Checkout Customization

The Buy with Prime button is standardized, meaning brands have limited flexibility in how it looks and integrates with their site. This could affect branding consistency.

Data Use Restrictions

While brands do receive customer data, Amazon prohibits sharing any information that identifies shoppers as Prime members with third parties. This limits retargeting efforts, as brands cannot use this data for external advertising platforms like Facebook Ads.

Dependency on Amazon’s Fulfillment Network

While Amazon’s fulfillment services are efficient, brands become reliant on Amazon’s logistics. Any policy changes, delays, or increased fees could directly impact profitability.

Is Buy with Prime Right for Your Brand?

The decision to adopt Buy with Prime depends on several factors:

Consider Buy with Prime if:

• You want to increase conversion rates with Prime’s trusted checkout process.
• Your business struggles with fulfillment logistics and would benefit from Amazon’s network.
• You sell high-margin products that can absorb the additional fees.

Think twice if:

• Your brand relies on branded checkout experiences and full customization.
• Your profit margins are too low to sustain extra fulfillment and processing fees.
• You want complete control over customer data usage for marketing.

Final Thoughts

With Adidas now adopting Buy with Prime, it’s clear that Amazon is expanding its reach beyond its marketplace. While the program offers trust, seamless checkout, and improved logistics, it also comes with fees, branding limitations, and data restrictions.

Before diving in, brands should weigh the costs, consider their fulfillment needs, and assess whether it aligns with their long-term business goals.

Would you consider using Buy with Prime? Let’s discuss in the comments.

Get a complimentary Amazon Ads audit to see how you can scale your sales efficiently